Teen (Joe Locke), Rio Vidal (Aubrey Plaza), Agatha Harkness (Kathryn Hahn) and Jennifer Kale (Sasheer Zamata) in Marvel Television’s ‘Agatha All Along.’ Chuck Zlotnick/Disney
“Agatha All Along,” the latest series from Disney+, began streaming on Wednesday, September 18, 2024. The new Marvel spinoff has left critics divided. Created by Jac Schaeffer, the show centers around Agatha Harkness, played by Kathryn Hahn, a character who first appeared in “WandaVision.” This time, the story explores her journey after regaining freedom, thanks to a mysterious character known as Teen, played by Joe Locke.
The series follows Agatha as she embarks on the Witches’ Road, a magical series of trials that could help her regain what she is missing. Along the way, she gathers a coven to aid in her quest. With such a magical premise, expectations were high, but the early reviews of the first four episodes have sparked a range of opinions.
The Hollywood Reporter’s Angie Han noted that while the series has potential, it suffers from “jerky pacing” and “relentless rug-pulling.” Han appreciated the cast and the cheeky tone but felt the show is more about brand extension than delivering a unique adventure. This sentiment was echoed by David Fear from Rolling Stone, who remarked that the show starts off by poking fun at serious superhero shows, but quickly settles into a typical Marvel adventure. Fear acknowledged the show’s fun moments but questioned whether it would maintain this momentum for the rest of the season.
However, not all critics were unimpressed. Taylor Gates from Collider praised Kathryn Hahn’s performance, calling it “magnetic” and highlighting her ability to blend theatricality with deeper emotional moments. Gates believed that while the show is full of sharp comedy and intriguing mysteries, it stands apart from other Marvel series. Hahn’s performance, according to Gates, grounds the show and adds vulnerability to the larger-than-life character of Agatha.
Mike Hale from The New York Times had a less favorable view, pointing out that while the theme of female empowerment is commendable, the plot feels generic. Hale also mentioned that the show’s attempts at humor don’t quite land, leaving the series feeling flat. He raised concerns over the show’s pacing and questioned whether it could sustain interest beyond the first few episodes.
Similarly, Ben Travers from Indiewire appreciated some aspects of the series but criticized its tendency to withhold information in favor of future plot twists. While the show’s episodic format seems better suited for TV compared to other MCU series, Travers felt that its reluctance to dive into character backstories detracts from the overall narrative.
On the other hand, Robert Lloyd from the Los Angeles Times found the series clever and funny. He appreciated the balance between the supernatural and the mundane, praising Hahn’s performance as both hilarious and relatable. Lloyd believed the show could surprise viewers as it progresses, offering a mix of suspense, humor, and even a few scares.
As with many Marvel shows, “Agatha All Along” faces the challenge of appealing to both casual viewers and die-hard fans of the MCU. Charles Pulliam-Moore from The Verge pointed out that the show’s success might depend on how much the audience is invested in the larger Marvel universe. While some may enjoy the playful nods to previous MCU events, others might find it harder to follow without that context.
IGN’s Joshua Yehl offered a more optimistic take, calling the show a “sinister good time.” Yehl praised the sharp writing and intriguing mysteries, noting that Agatha’s character has room to grow as the season unfolds. While acknowledging that the story feels rushed at times, Yehl expressed hope that the foundation laid in the first few episodes would pay off later.
As the series continues, it will have seven more episodes to win over audiences and critics alike. With Kathryn Hahn’s compelling performance at the center, there is potential for “Agatha All Along” to evolve into something truly memorable. However, only time will tell if the show can balance its blend of humor, suspense, and character development to deliver a satisfying conclusion.
In the meantime, fans of the Marvel universe and newcomers alike can enjoy the twists and turns of Agatha’s journey down the Witches’ Road, hoping for the best from Marvel’s latest magical endeavor.
“Magic is believing in yourself. If you can do that, you can make anything happen.” – Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
#AgathaAllAlong #MarvelSeries #KathrynHahn #DisneyPlus #MarvelSpinoff